NYG
61.6MANIA RATINGDepth Overall QB Rating
MANIA RATING

J.J. McCarthy

NYG · QB · 4 games
#31 Overall QB#15 Projected QBUnderrated
70.3WEEK 11 RATINGWeek 11 · vs. JAX
15.3WEEK 11 PROJECTIONPPR
12.7PPR / GAMEseason average
QB31QB RANKthis season
Games counted
Untick or tick any game and Mania Rating and the breakdown recalculate. Official Mania Rating 61.6.
12.7
PPR / Game
229
Pass Yds / Game
0.5
Pass TD / Game
0.5
INT / Game
63.5%
Completion %
8.8
Yards / Attempt
21
Rush Yds / Game
Mania breakdown
Production27
Passing41
Rushing60
Scoring9
Efficiency61
Mania breakdown
Percentile among quarterbacks. 100 is the best, 50 is average.
| 35% Weight
27
Fantasy points per game (PPR) against other quarterbacks. The biggest single piece, because points are what you start him for. Ranks better than 27% of quarterbacks.
PPR / game 28th
| 15% Weight
41
60% passing yards per game, 40% attempts per game. More throws and more yards mean a safer floor. Ranks better than 41% of quarterbacks.
Pass yards 18thAttempts 31st
| 12% Weight
60
65% rushing yards per game, 35% rushing touchdowns per game. Quarterbacks who run get a big fantasy boost. Ranks better than 60% of quarterbacks.
Rush yards 9thRush TDs 24th
| 13% Weight
9
60% passing touchdowns per game, 40% how often his throws turn into touchdowns. Ranks better than 9% of quarterbacks.
Pass TDs 32ndTD rate 31st
| 25% Weight
61
How well he actually plays, not just how much: 35% scoring impact (points he adds per throw), 20% accuracy, 15% yards per throw, 15% few interceptions, 15% few sacks. Ranks better than 61% of quarterbacks.
Scoring impact 15thAccuracy 9thYards / throw 2ndInterceptions 13thSacks 26th
Top 30%MiddleBottom 40%Tap a category to see what it means.
Week 11 projection
15.3
projected points
Floor 5.2 · Ceiling 25.6
-0.8Game script
0.0Matchup
0.0Injuries
Week 11 projection
NYG
VSPPR
JAX
Tough matchup • JAX is #28 in points allowed to QBs
15.3
projected points212 pass yds, 1.3 pass TD, 0.7 INT • 18 rush yds
Floor 5.24 of 5 games land hereCeiling 25.6
Vegas lines included. From usage alone: 14.2. Sportsbook lines imply 16.1. Blended: 15.3. Biggest gaps: passing TDs 1.50 on the sportsbooks vs 1.13 from usage; passing yards 218 on the sportsbooks vs 202 from usage.
-0.8Game script
0.0Matchup
0.0Injuries
How this is built
Recent and last-season usage, the Vegas spread and total, how this defense treats his position, and the injury report (teammates out, receivers out). The three boxes show how many points each moved it. When sportsbook player lines are posted (Wednesday to Sunday) they are blended in, leaning on them most for new starters and players with few games. PPR scoring only; QBs get 4 per passing TD, 1 per 25 yards, -2 per INT. Tested on past seasons it is about 10% closer than a plain season average.
Game log
16.3W6
10.2W7
7.3W9
17.1W10
Games4
PPR/G12.7
Game log
16.3W610.2W77.3W917.1W10
McCarthy avg 12.7NFL top 12 QBs avg 20.9
Solid dot is what he scored. Hollow dot is our projection before the game.
GameProjPPRCmp/AttPass YdTDINTRush YdRush TD
W6 NO—16.311/2124311260
W7 HOU—10.220/282520010
W9 PHI—7.312/1912700220
W10 WAS—17.123/3629311340
Opponent color:Easy for QBsAverageTough
Schedule ahead
11 JAX12 IND13 SF14 SEA15 CLE16 DET17 DAL18 PHI
Green easier, red tougher
Schedule ahead
Colored by what each defense has given up to QBs so far. Green is an easier matchup, red is a tougher one.
Wk 11 JAXWk 12 INDWk 13 SFWk 14 SEAWk 15 CLEWk 16 DETWk 17 DALWk 18 PHI
See every team's QB schedule ›
The real story
Better than his points
His play is better than his fantasy points.
The real story
Better than his pointsHis play is better than his fantasy points. Fewer attempts or a slow offense is holding the numbers down, so he has room to rise.
Points scoredFantasy points per game
27
How well he playsScoring impact, accuracy, sacks, turnovers
61
Each bar is a percentile among quarterbacks. 100 is the best, 50 is average. Points scored above How well he plays can mean his teammates are helping. The other way around means he is better than his stats look.
The team around him
A lot of help
81Line
81Weapons
81Catching
94Overall
Tap to open
The team around him

How much help he gets. Tap any circle to see all quarterbacks ranked.

Compared with starting quarterbacks.
81#7 of 32Offensive lineStrong • pressured 20% (avg 23%)See ranking ›
81#7 of 32WeaponsStrong • Malik Nabers, Isaiah Likely, Cam SkatteboSee ranking ›
63#7 of 32After the catchAverage • 5.3 yds per catch, 4 dropsSee ranking ›
77#3 of 32Overall helpA lot of helpSee ranking ›
He gets a lot of help. Some of his numbers belong to his teammates.
Starters are quarterbacks who are first on their team’s depth chart or have taken at least half of their team’s dropbacks. Weapons use the current Mania Rating of his best three receivers, tight end and back. Anyone who is out this week does not count. Pressure rate depends a little on how long he holds the ball, and yards after the catch depend a little on the scheme, so treat this as a good guide, not a final grade.
By the numbers
PPR points / G
12.7
Pass yards / G
229
Pass TDs / G
0.5
Interceptions / G
0.5
By the numbers
PPR points per game
12.7
28th of 32QB avg 16.5
Passing yards per game
229
18th of 32QB avg 233
Passing TDs per game
0.5
32nd of 32QB avg 1.5
Interceptions per game
0.5
9th of 32QB avg 0.7
Completion rate
63.5%
20th of 32QB avg 64.0%
Yards per attempt
8.8
2nd of 32QB avg 7.2
Rushing yards per game
21
9th of 32QB avg 15
Rushing TDs per game
0.00
24th of 32QB avg 0.18
Advanced passing
Scoring impact15th of 32
Accuracy9th of 32
Avoids sacks26th of 32
Open for the full breakdown
How a QB is rated
Mania Rating61.6
Quarterback rankQB31 of 44
Open to see how it is built
How a QB is rated
  1. Grade five categories.Each bar on the left is his percentile among quarterbacks. 100 is the best, 50 is average.
  2. Blend them.Production 35%, Passing 15%, Rushing 12%, Scoring 13%, Efficiency 25%. Production counts the most, and Efficiency (how well he plays: scoring impact, accuracy, sacks, interceptions) is next, so a QB cannot rate high on empty volume alone.Blend 39.5
  3. Match it to the whole league.He is QB31 of 44. That spot is lined up with the same spot among running backs, receivers and tight ends, so QB1 is rated like WR1.Mania Rating 61.6
  4. Week 11 rating.This week's projected points, graded on the same scale.
Where he sits
30. M. Penix Jr.61.8
31. J. McCarthy61.6
32. C. Keenum60.4
Where he sits

The quarterbacks right around him in Mania Rating. Tap a name to open his profile.

#PlayerPPR / GMania
28Jacoby BrissettBAL13.763.6
29Gardner MinshewARI13.363.6
30Michael Penix Jr.ATL13.661.8
31J.J. McCarthyNYG12.761.6
32Case KeenumCHI12.660.4
33Cam WardTEN13.359.9
34Jalon DanielsTB12.158.4
How quarterbacks did against JAX

13.1 PPR points a game allowed to quarterbacks, 28th most of 32 defenses.

PlayerPPRPass YdPass TDIntRush Yd
Joe Burrow@ CIN • Wk 423.7428126
C.J. Stroudvs HOU • Wk 623.0312315
Cam Ward@ TEN • Wk 1019.12312139
Bo Nix@ DEN • Wk 214.1288116
Deshaun Watsonvs CLE • Wk 114.02051138
Jalen Hurtsvs PHI • Wk 513.0220102
Daniel Jonesvs IND • Wk 86.5144127
Drake Mayevs NE • Wk 33.81990218
Tommy DeVitovs NE • Wk 31.430002
Joe Fagnano@ BAL • Wk 9-0.3600213

Fantasy points first, then the stats that matter for his position. Ring around each photo is that player's Mania Rating. Tap a name to open his profile.

StatPer gameSeasonRank
Overall
Games—4—
PPR points12.750.913›
Passing
Passing yards22991545›
Passing TDs0.520›
Interceptions0.5274›
Completions—66—
Attempts26104—
Completion %63.5%63.5%39›
Yards per attempt8.8—97›
Rushing
Rush yards218374›
Rush TDs0.00026›
Carries3.2——
Tap any stat to see everyone ranked. Bars: green top 30%, yellow middle, red bottom 40%.
Advanced passing

The same stats the pros use, in plain words. Green means better than most of the 32 QBs. The small mark on each bar is the QB average.

Scoring impactAverage
+0.10 points added per throw
15th of 32 QBs · average +0.06See everyone ›
AccuracyGood
+3.4% completions beyond what is expected
9th of 32 QBs · average +0.8%See everyone ›
Avoids sacksBelow average
8.8% of dropbacks end in a sack
26th of 32 QBs · average 6.8%See everyone ›
Bad throwsBelow average
16.3% of throws miss the target
25th of 32 QBs · average 14.8%See everyone ›
Throw depthDeep passer
9.8 yards, on average, the ball travels
1st of 32 QBs · average 7.9See everyone ›
Pressure he facesClean pocket
20.2% of dropbacks are pressured
7th of 32 QBs · average 23.3%See everyone ›
Dropped passesContext
4 passes his receivers dropped
Not his fault, but every drop costs him fantasy points.
NYG
61.6
Mania Rating
Depth Overall QB Rating
70.3
Week 11 Rating
Week 11 · vs. JAX

J.J. McCarthy

NYG · QB · 4 games
#31 Overall QB#15 Projected QBUnderrated
Week 11 projection 15.3 PPR ›
Games counted
Untick or tick any game and Mania Rating and the breakdown recalculate. Official Mania Rating 61.6.
Week 11 projection
15.3
projected points
Floor 5.2 · Ceiling 25.6
-0.8Game script
0.0Matchup
0.0Injuries
Week 11 projection
NYG
VSPPR
JAX
Tough matchup • JAX is #28 in points allowed to QBs
15.3
projected points212 pass yds, 1.3 pass TD, 0.7 INT • 18 rush yds
Floor 5.24 of 5 games land hereCeiling 25.6
Vegas lines included. From usage alone: 14.2. Sportsbook lines imply 16.1. Blended: 15.3. Biggest gaps: passing TDs 1.50 on the sportsbooks vs 1.13 from usage; passing yards 218 on the sportsbooks vs 202 from usage.
-0.8Game script
0.0Matchup
0.0Injuries
How this is built
Recent and last-season usage, the Vegas spread and total, how this defense treats his position, and the injury report (teammates out, receivers out). The three boxes show how many points each moved it. When sportsbook player lines are posted (Wednesday to Sunday) they are blended in, leaning on them most for new starters and players with few games. PPR scoring only; QBs get 4 per passing TD, 1 per 25 yards, -2 per INT. Tested on past seasons it is about 10% closer than a plain season average.
Game log
16.3W6
10.2W7
7.3W9
17.1W10
Games4
PPR/G12.7
Game log
16.3W610.2W77.3W917.1W10
McCarthy avg 12.7NFL top 12 QBs avg 20.9
Solid dot is what he scored. Hollow dot is our projection before the game.
GameProjPPRCmp/AttPass YdTDINTRush YdRush TD
W6 NO—16.311/2124311260
W7 HOU—10.220/282520010
W9 PHI—7.312/1912700220
W10 WAS—17.123/3629311340
Opponent color:Easy for QBsAverageTough
Schedule ahead
11 JAX12 IND13 SF14 SEA15 CLE16 DET17 DAL18 PHI
Green easier, red tougher
Schedule ahead
Colored by what each defense has given up to QBs so far. Green is an easier matchup, red is a tougher one.
Wk 11 JAXWk 12 INDWk 13 SFWk 14 SEAWk 15 CLEWk 16 DETWk 17 DALWk 18 PHI
See every team's QB schedule ›
The team around him
A lot of help
81Line
81Weapons
81Catching
94Overall
Tap to open
The team around him

How much help he gets. Tap any circle to see all quarterbacks ranked.

Compared with starting quarterbacks.
81#7 of 32Offensive lineStrong • pressured 20% (avg 23%)See ranking ›
81#7 of 32WeaponsStrong • Malik Nabers, Isaiah Likely, Cam SkatteboSee ranking ›
63#7 of 32After the catchAverage • 5.3 yds per catch, 4 dropsSee ranking ›
77#3 of 32Overall helpA lot of helpSee ranking ›
He gets a lot of help. Some of his numbers belong to his teammates.
Starters are quarterbacks who are first on their team’s depth chart or have taken at least half of their team’s dropbacks. Weapons use the current Mania Rating of his best three receivers, tight end and back. Anyone who is out this week does not count. Pressure rate depends a little on how long he holds the ball, and yards after the catch depend a little on the scheme, so treat this as a good guide, not a final grade.
Advanced passing
Scoring impact15th of 32
Accuracy9th of 32
Avoids sacks26th of 32
Open for the full breakdown
Where he sits
30. M. Penix Jr.61.8
31. J. McCarthy61.6
32. C. Keenum60.4
Where he sits

The quarterbacks right around him in Mania Rating. Tap a name to open his profile.

#PlayerPPR / GMania
28Jacoby BrissettBAL13.763.6
29Gardner MinshewARI13.363.6
30Michael Penix Jr.ATL13.661.8
31J.J. McCarthyNYG12.761.6
32Case KeenumCHI12.660.4
33Cam WardTEN13.359.9
34Jalon DanielsTB12.158.4
StatPer gameSeasonRank
Overall
Games—4—
PPR points12.750.913›
Passing
Passing yards22991545›
Passing TDs0.520›
Interceptions0.5274›
Completions—66—
Attempts26104—
Completion %63.5%63.5%39›
Yards per attempt8.8—97›
Rushing
Rush yards218374›
Rush TDs0.00026›
Carries3.2——
Tap any stat to see everyone ranked. Bars: green top 30%, yellow middle, red bottom 40%.
Advanced passing

The same stats the pros use, in plain words. Green means better than most of the 32 QBs. The small mark on each bar is the QB average.

Scoring impactAverage
+0.10 points added per throw
15th of 32 QBs · average +0.06See everyone ›
AccuracyGood
+3.4% completions beyond what is expected
9th of 32 QBs · average +0.8%See everyone ›
Avoids sacksBelow average
8.8% of dropbacks end in a sack
26th of 32 QBs · average 6.8%See everyone ›
Bad throwsBelow average
16.3% of throws miss the target
25th of 32 QBs · average 14.8%See everyone ›
Throw depthDeep passer
9.8 yards, on average, the ball travels
1st of 32 QBs · average 7.9See everyone ›
Pressure he facesClean pocket
20.2% of dropbacks are pressured
7th of 32 QBs · average 23.3%See everyone ›
Dropped passesContext
4 passes his receivers dropped
Not his fault, but every drop costs him fantasy points.
Mania breakdown
Production27
Passing41
Rushing60
Scoring9
Efficiency61
Mania breakdown
Percentile among quarterbacks. 100 is the best, 50 is average.
| 35% Weight
27
Fantasy points per game (PPR) against other quarterbacks. The biggest single piece, because points are what you start him for. Ranks better than 27% of quarterbacks.
PPR / game 28th
| 15% Weight
41
60% passing yards per game, 40% attempts per game. More throws and more yards mean a safer floor. Ranks better than 41% of quarterbacks.
Pass yards 18thAttempts 31st
| 12% Weight
60
65% rushing yards per game, 35% rushing touchdowns per game. Quarterbacks who run get a big fantasy boost. Ranks better than 60% of quarterbacks.
Rush yards 9thRush TDs 24th
| 13% Weight
9
60% passing touchdowns per game, 40% how often his throws turn into touchdowns. Ranks better than 9% of quarterbacks.
Pass TDs 32ndTD rate 31st
| 25% Weight
61
How well he actually plays, not just how much: 35% scoring impact (points he adds per throw), 20% accuracy, 15% yards per throw, 15% few interceptions, 15% few sacks. Ranks better than 61% of quarterbacks.
Scoring impact 15thAccuracy 9thYards / throw 2ndInterceptions 13thSacks 26th
Top 30%MiddleBottom 40%Tap a category to see what it means.
How quarterbacks did against JAX

13.1 PPR points a game allowed to quarterbacks, 28th most of 32 defenses.

PlayerPPRPass YdPass TDIntRush Yd
Joe Burrow@ CIN • Wk 423.7428126
C.J. Stroudvs HOU • Wk 623.0312315
Cam Ward@ TEN • Wk 1019.12312139
Bo Nix@ DEN • Wk 214.1288116
Deshaun Watsonvs CLE • Wk 114.02051138
Jalen Hurtsvs PHI • Wk 513.0220102
Daniel Jonesvs IND • Wk 86.5144127
Drake Mayevs NE • Wk 33.81990218
Tommy DeVitovs NE • Wk 31.430002
Joe Fagnano@ BAL • Wk 9-0.3600213

Fantasy points first, then the stats that matter for his position. Ring around each photo is that player's Mania Rating. Tap a name to open his profile.

The real story
Better than his points
His play is better than his fantasy points.
The real story
Better than his pointsHis play is better than his fantasy points. Fewer attempts or a slow offense is holding the numbers down, so he has room to rise.
Points scoredFantasy points per game
27
How well he playsScoring impact, accuracy, sacks, turnovers
61
Each bar is a percentile among quarterbacks. 100 is the best, 50 is average. Points scored above How well he plays can mean his teammates are helping. The other way around means he is better than his stats look.
By the numbers
PPR points / G
12.7
Pass yards / G
229
Pass TDs / G
0.5
Interceptions / G
0.5
By the numbers
PPR points per game
12.7
28th of 32QB avg 16.5
Passing yards per game
229
18th of 32QB avg 233
Passing TDs per game
0.5
32nd of 32QB avg 1.5
Interceptions per game
0.5
9th of 32QB avg 0.7
Completion rate
63.5%
20th of 32QB avg 64.0%
Yards per attempt
8.8
2nd of 32QB avg 7.2
Rushing yards per game
21
9th of 32QB avg 15
Rushing TDs per game
0.00
24th of 32QB avg 0.18
12.7
PPR / Game
229
Pass Yds / Game
0.5
Pass TD / Game
0.5
INT / Game
63.5%
Completion %
8.8
Yards / Attempt
21
Rush Yds / Game
How a QB is rated
Mania Rating61.6
Quarterback rankQB31 of 44
Open to see how it is built
How a QB is rated
  1. Grade five categories.Each bar on the left is his percentile among quarterbacks. 100 is the best, 50 is average.
  2. Blend them.Production 35%, Passing 15%, Rushing 12%, Scoring 13%, Efficiency 25%. Production counts the most, and Efficiency (how well he plays: scoring impact, accuracy, sacks, interceptions) is next, so a QB cannot rate high on empty volume alone.Blend 39.5
  3. Match it to the whole league.He is QB31 of 44. That spot is lined up with the same spot among running backs, receivers and tight ends, so QB1 is rated like WR1.Mania Rating 61.6
  4. Week 11 rating.This week's projected points, graded on the same scale.

More on J.J. McCarthy

Start/sit this week

More QBs

Rankings

Tools

Mania Ratings and projections through Week 10 of the 2026 season, updated during the week. Tap anything above to open the full interactive profile in Fantasy Mania.